We conducted a retrospective casecontrol study among persons aged 50 to 89 years who received a radiograph of the right hand during the last 5 years. Where did the myth knuckle cracking causes arthritis. Cracking your knuckles causes arthritis 9 medical myths. D who works with our doctors online partners at edocamerica.
One study found that there was no increase of hand arthritis among knuckle crackers, however, knuckle cracking was related to hand swelling and lower grip strength. Find out about why this happens with an ra diagnosis. Consider the information below for a demystification of the action itself. For most others, cracking the knuckles is merely an indulgence or a habit. The truth behind 5 osteoarthritis myths health plus. Knuckles are lubricated by synovial fluid, a yolklike substance that reduces friction between the bones, easing movement. Jan 21, 2017 its hard to truly tell where most myths originate, but it may have to do with arthritis sufferers noticing their joints cracking. These joints are surrounded and lubricated by synovial fluid, a thick, clear liquid. As for the crack or pop noise you hear after you crack your knuckles, its not bad either although it may annoy the people around you. So its often thought that if you engage in repetitive activity and put. Close to the knuckle in fact, very few studies have been carried out at all.
Jan 27, 2020 knuckle cracking causes arthritis cracking knuckles or fingers is something most of us learn to do when we are younger. Cracking your knuckles causes arthritis the knuckles are the joints between the fingers and hand, and these joints contain a lubricant called synovial fluid. Mar 26, 2020 there are gas bubbles that form in the synovial fluid or joint fluid and the action of bending your knuckle is like adding pressure to a balloon until it pops. However, cracking your knuckles is neither harmless nor desirable.
While the rate of receiving a total joint replacement is great for ages 6485, younger adults are more frequently receiving total joint replacements every year. There is no evidence that cracking knuckles causes any damage such as arthritis in the joints. Worried that cracking your fingers and joints will give you arthritis. For our october 2011 issue, we asked dimitrios pappas, md, assistant professor of medicine at columbia universitys college of. For others, its a way to pass time while pondering a. The pop of a cracked knuckle is just an air bubble in your joint fluid bursting. If you enjoy cracking your knuckles, know that doctors suggest pulling on a joint, rather than bending, since it is the safest way of getting the feeling of relief.
Aug, 2018 theres a long list of myths and superstitions about knuckle cracking, but the one you probably heard most often was delivered by irritated parents or teachers when you were a kid. Scientists still cant pinpoint why are joints make a cracking sound but, according to extensive research, theres no proof that knucklecracking damages the joints one scientist was so keen. Published in 2011, the retrospective casecontrol study compared knucklecracking history between older adults with and without radiographicevidence of oa. Study conclusions on whether knuckle cracking causes arthritis. Several studies have shown that knuckle cracking doesnt raise the risk of arthritis. Perhaps one of the most wellknown is the selfinflicted research rewarded with an ig nobel prize in 2009. Knuckles are the joints between your fingers and your hands.
The bottom line here is that cracking your knuckles generally does not lead to arthritis. The department of orthopedics noted there is no evidence that knuckle cracking causes arthritis. One myth that exists states that repeated knuckle cracking will lead to arthritis. Previous studies have not shown a correlation between knuckle cracking kc and hand osteoarthritis oa. Can cracking your knuckles cause cartilage breakdown. One of the joints that is most associated with cracking along with others such as the neck and knees is the knuckle. Some students crack their knuckles after writing a great deal, but. Busting the myth about knuckle cracking chicago health. Thats the conclusion of several studies that compared rates of hand arthritis among habitual knuckle crackers and people who didnt crack their knuckles. Knuckle cracking doesnt really have anything to do with friction between joints, which is the common misunderstandinginstead, the popping sound comes from gas bubbles in the fluid that cushions the finger bones. Jan 21, 2015 despite warnings from your grandparents that youll suffer a life of arthritis if you sit around cracking your knuckles, this myth is busted. Racket or paddle sports may offer greatest benefits.
People keep telling me to stop cracking my knuckles. However, a couple of reports in the medical literature are available associating knuckle cracking with injury of the ligaments surrounding the joint or dislocation of the tendons attachments of muscles to bones which improved with conservative. Cracking knuckles or fingers is something most of us learn to do when we are younger. In a time when medical science still was not developed enough to establish the cause and effect link between every minute action of the human body, corelating cracking of joints to arthritis and other painful joint conditions was an easy. It usually takes about 20 minutes for the bubbles to form again. Mar 08, 2019 the department of orthopedics noted there is no evidence that knuckle cracking causes arthritis. Orthopedic myths knuckle cracking, surgery misconceptions. When launching an exercise routine with arthritis, look for a custom fit. Im not saying definitely no because, while cracking knuckles is common, research on its effects is not.
It can become a habit or a way to deal with nervous energy. Knuckle cracking has not been shown to be harmful or beneficial. Urban legend would indicate that knuckle cracking leads to arthritis of the joints of the hand. Possibly, this statement became a weapon in the arsenal of those who were averse to the knuckle cracking habits of others. The repetitive motion of cracking your knuckles wears down the joints and their protective cushioning. Arthritis causes knuckle cracking, not the other way around. The truth and the myth behind the cracking knuckles debate. However, one study showed an inverse correlation between kc and metacarpophalangeal joint oa. Sep 25, 2016 professor conaghan, a spokesman for arthritis research uk, adds. Sep 20, 20 the bottom line here is that cracking your knuckles generally does not lead to arthritis. Cracking of joints does not cause arthritis hearing your joints let out a loud pop can be a tad unsettling. We re cracking myths while you crack your knuckles. Mainstreet tackles the most prevalent medical myths. If you have any arthritis or other orthopedic concerns, be.
Medical science has thus far failed to prove any genuine connection between the two. Knuckle cracking, damp weather, nightshade foods and more arthritis myths dispelled as the arthritis is so common medical problem affecting millions of people around the world, it is not surprising that a number of myths that appeared many of us have come to regard as the real facts. A mathematic model for the sounds produced by knuckle cracking. Nowadays, the causes of arthritis are better understoodjoint. It would be a gross overstatement, however, to say that the medical literature has thoroughly explored this connection. No doubt youve been told this a million or so times. Knuckle cracking is a common behavior enjoyed by many. Cracking your knuckles may aggravate the people around you, but it probably wont raise your risk for arthritis. In fact, one study analyzed the trend of knee replacements done in adults aged 4564 over a ten year period ending. Theres a long list of myths and superstitions about knuckle cracking, but the one you probably heard most often was delivered by irritated parents or teachers when you were a kid. May 30, 2012 when each group was asked about knuckle cracking habits, it actually turned out that those who didnt crack their knuckles had slightly greater rates of arthritis 18. Scientists actually looked into it and found no evidence that habitual knucklecrackers were at an increased risk of developing hand oa. More specifically, knuckle cracking does not cause arthritis. Sometimes this fascination leads to neck cracking and back cracking.
Certain myths as to the potential sideeffects of cracking ones knuckles have sprung up over the years, and this article will now examine the truth, if any, behind these myths. Sometimes knuckles feel tight, so people try to get a release by cracking them. Knuckle cracking doesnt cause arthritis, but some research suggests the habit may not be completely harmless. More than 100 different types of arthritis are known by far. According to a medical myths column by claudia hammond of, the space between the joints increases, causing the gases dissolved in the synovial fluid bathing the joint to. The arthritis connection may be an old wives tale, but cracking your knuckles can hurt your hand in other ways, and theres no benefit to it. Arthritis and cracking knuckles the reason people associate knuckle cracking with arthritis because it makes a cracking noise and, if something cracks, it must be being damaged.
Arthritis can occur because of a variety of reasons ranging from your age, genes, infections, etc. As most of us who did it can attest, sooner or later you will encounter someone who gives you the dire warnings that, one day, all your knuckle cracking will result in agonising arthritis. There are two people in this worldthose who crack their knuckles and everyone else who finds it revolting. To set the record straight, weve listed 10 of the most common myths about the human body. Some get hooked and form a habit of cracking knuckles on a frequent basis. Many people crack their knuckles out of nervous habit, or to annoy those who tell them to stop because it will give them arthritis. Osteoarthritis oa, sometimes called wear and tear arthritis, occurs when the cartilage or cushion between joints breaks down leading to pain, stiffness and swelling. If knuckle cracking proves painful, there could be an abnormality in the structure of the joint. As a middle school student, i remember being told that cracking your knuckles would give you arthritis.
Possibly, this statement became a weapon in the arsenal of those who were averse to the knucklecracking habits of others. Have you ever heard the myth that cracking your knuckles breaks the. For our october 2011 issue, we asked dimitrios pappas, md, assistant professor of medicine at. As most of us who did it can attest, sooner or later you will encounter someone who gives you the dire warnings that, one day, all your knucklecracking will result in agonising arthritis. Aug 22, 2014 experiencing joints cracking, popping, and making snapping sounds with rheumatoid arthritis is common. Sep 21, 2010 does knuckle cracking lead to arthritis. However, repeatedly cracking your knuckles may cause temporary soreness of the joint. There are gas bubbles that form in the synovial fluid or joint fluid and the action of bending your knuckle is like adding pressure to a balloon until it pops. Some studies imply knuckle cracking may lead to some hand swelling and weakness later in life, but again, there are no studies that prove this direct connection. If you fall into the latter category quite why anyone. Understanding what physically occurs when you crack your knuckles will help you realize that the knuckle cracking causes arthritis theory is actually just a popular myth.
May 18, 2019 cracking your knuckles does not cause arthritis. Thats right or at the very least plausible that youve had it backwards all these years. Apr 21, 2017 knuckle cracking doesnt cause arthritis, but some research suggests the habit may not be completely harmless. Aug 03, 2019 more than 100 different types of arthritis are known by far. An orthopedic surgeon answers the ageold question about cracking your knuckles and arthritis plus explains why you hear a pop noise when. However, knuckle cracking may be associated with tendon and other soft tissue problems. Scientists have conducted fairly rigorous research into the long held belief that cracking your knuckles will give you arthritis, and theyve all come to largely the same conclusionits. There are no definitive links between knuckle cracking and arthritis or any other medical condition. Jun 17, 2015 ironically, 25 years later my childhood friends joints are doing great, and i am the one with arthritis. A doctor cracked his own knuckles for 60 years to prove it. Sep 11, 2015 a number of studies have been done over the years to find out the longterm impact of cracking your knuckles. Also ironic is that my ra has caused me to become a knucklecracker. Thats the conclusion of several studies that compared rates of hand arthritis among habitual knucklecrackers and people who didnt crack their knuckles.
Some people like hearing the sound knuckle cracking makes. Osteoarthritis is the most common arthritis, which is often considered in the case of knuckle cracking. You can hear more medical myths on health check on the bbc world service. Knuckle cracking myth musculoskeletal issues articles. Arthritis and cracking knuckles the reason people associate knucklecracking with arthritis because it makes a cracking noise and, if something cracks, it. Although cracking your knuckles has not been shown to explicitly cause arthritis, that doesnt mean that it is completely without consequences. Cracking your knuckles gives you arthritis readers. If a joint gets locked when it pops, knuckle cracking could lead to injuries in. Oct 09, 2018 scientists have conducted fairly rigorous research into the long held belief that cracking your knuckles will give you arthritis, and theyve all come to largely the same conclusionits.
Debbie yi, an emergency medicine and neurology physician at the hospital of upenn says. For some its a morning ritual cracking your knuckles before beginning the day. Knuckle cracking, damp weather, nightshade foods and more arthritis myths dispelled as the arthritis is so common medical problem affecting millions of people around the world, it is not surprising that a number of myths that appeared many. The truth behind 6 arthritis myths expert tips and.
When each group was asked about knucklecracking habits, it actually turned out that those who didnt crack their knuckles had slightly greater rates of arthritis 18. Arthritis is a common ailment affecting millions, and myths such as whether cracking knuckles causes it lead to confusion and can get in the way of effectively dealing with arthritis. None shows a definite link between knuckle cracking and arthritis. Stop cracking those knuckles or youll end up giving yourself arthritis. Sometimes knucklecrackers can go too far and the resulting pop is actually the sound of a dislocated joint or broken bone. Knuckle cracking and hand osteoarthritis american board. During that period, your joints feel looser and relieved from the pressure, which is the whole appeal to knuckle cracking. There have been a few studies over the years that considered whether or not cracking knuckles caused arthritis. There is no age prerequisite to total joint replacements.
The most recent and most methodologicallysound investigation on the association between knucklecracking and oa came from the journal of the american board of family medicine jabfm. Knuckle cracking and hand osteoarthritis american board of. There is no medical evidence that knuckle cracking causes arthritis. Despite warnings from your grandparents that youll suffer a life of arthritis if you sit around cracking your knuckles, this myth is busted. Knuckle cracking, damp weather, nightshade foods and more. Knuckle crackers may find pleasure from their practice despite the annoyance or warnings of damage from others, but concerns about arthritis are apparently myths.
The fascination with knuckle cracking often starts at an early age. Currently theres no substantial evidence that shows knuckle cracking leads to arthritis. Many people worry, though, that it could cause arthritis. At that time, i had no idea that there were millions of americans with rheumatoid arthritis, much less that within a decade i would become one of them, so i didnt understand that young people can get arthritis. There have been multiple studies over the years and all of them show no connection between knuckle cracking and arthritis. Does cracking my knuckles increase my risk of arthritis. I thought popping knuckles would give me arthritis, but instead my arthritis has given me knuckle popping. In general form, it is the inflammation of your joints that is caused due to various reasons including autoimmune problems, bacterial infection, or stds. When you crack your knuckles, you are pulling apart two bones at the joint, which means the synovial fluid has to fill more space. Cracking your knuckles or popping your joints causes osteoarthritis as annoying as it may be to some, cracking your knuckles or occasionally hearing a popping sound from your knee sans any pain is harmless and does not cause arthritis. If you are one of those people who sits and cracks your knuckles while. Studies show that as many as 54 percent of people crack their knuckles.
A few medical literature do say that a habitual cracking over several years may cause temporary soreness, swollen hands, and reduced strength of. Kids think its cool to hear that popping and crackling sound that emanates from their joints when they bend and twist them. We conducted a retrospective casecontrol study among persons aged 50 to 89 years who received a radiograph of the right hand. Cracking knuckles that trigger or accompanies pain, however, can be a sign of an underlying wound.
1372 710 170 761 712 1487 456 894 1378 1076 293 261 760 274 1392 524 352 853 115 1267 142 686 1403 95 1251 334 512 240 729 819 1507 1493 152 991 609 641 1343 883 361 839 793 499 368 1067 297